Military Administrative Law
Helmsing Military Law, PLLC. Trusted Counsel
← All blog posts

FROM NATALIA

The Pentagon Changed How Military Boards Review Certain Discharges. Is Yours Worth a Second Look?

By Natalia Helmsing

Imagine a Soldier’s Army separation packet. It lists every formation he missed but says little about what changed after he returned from deployment. Years later, he’s diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and someone who served with him remembers when he started having trouble. Can that evidence help him challenge his discharge, even if he did miss the formations that led to his separation?

It can. Federal law gives the military departments authority to correct a record to remedy an error or an injustice. That second ground matters for veterans who accept responsibility for their conduct and still have good reason to question the discharge they received. Between 2014 and 2018, the Department of Defense issued four memoranda explaining how its boards should exercise that authority. In 2021, a group of Army veterans secured a settlement under which the Army agreed to take a second look at certain cases it had already decided. 10 U.S.C. § 1552(a)(1), Army Review Boards Agency publications, Kennedy settlement agreement, § IV

Hagel and Carson gave veterans with older discharges a way back

Consider what it meant to ask a Vietnam veteran for proof that a military clinician had diagnosed PTSD. For many veterans, the military had already discharged them before PTSD was even recognized as a diagnosis. Their records might describe nightmares, trouble sleeping, or a sharp change in behavior. The diagnosis that helped make sense of those entries might come decades later. VA National Center for PTSD, history of the diagnosis

Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel addressed that problem in September 2014. He directed the military records correction boards to give liberal consideration to evidence that PTSD or a related condition existed during service and may have contributed to the misconduct behind an other than honorable discharge. A later civilian diagnosis could matter. A VA determination documenting service-connected PTSD warranted special consideration. The board still had to weigh the seriousness of the misconduct, but the absence of the letters “PTSD” from an old medical chart no longer settled the question. Hagel memorandum, supplemental guidance

The Carson memo addressed the veteran who had already tried. In February 2016, Brad Carson directed correction boards to waive a filing deadline when it would prevent consideration of a covered PTSD or traumatic brain injury petition. If a board had already decided the case without the benefit of the supplemental guidance, the veteran could petition for de novo review. In plain English, the veteran could ask the board to decide the case afresh under the applicable guidance. For someone with a denial letter in hand, the date and reasoning in that letter could be as important as the date on the DD Form 214. Carson memorandum, February 24, 2016, Kurta memorandum, paragraph 23

Kurta explained what counts as evidence

In August 2017, the Kurta memo gave both discharge review boards and boards for correction of military or naval records a clearer way to evaluate cases involving mental health conditions, traumatic brain injury, sexual assault, or sexual harassment. It asked boards to work through four questions. What condition or experience might explain the discharge? Did it exist or occur during service? How did it bear on the conduct that led to separation? And, after weighing the evidence, did it justify changing the discharge? Kurta memorandum, paragraph 2

For a veteran who never reported a sexual assault, those questions can change what goes into an application. The veteran’s own account is evidence. A roommate may remember a sudden move out of the barracks. A supervisor may recall that a previously dependable service member started missing duty only after being assigned to work with a particular person. Those witnesses can describe what they saw even if the veteran never told them why. The board can weigh that evidence alongside the service record and any later treatment records. It must still consider how closely the experience relates to the particular misconduct and how serious that misconduct was. Kurta memorandum, paragraphs 4–7 and 16–19

Kurta also matters for veterans who already have an honorable discharge. Sometimes the entry that warrants correction is the narrative reason for separation or the reenlistment code. A veteran whose military record still carries a separation reason tied to a disputed diagnosis may care far more about correcting that entry than changing the characterization of service. Kurta expressly reaches those requests. Kurta memorandum, paragraphs 17, 20, and 24

Wilkie made room for what happened after service

Some veterans have no medical explanation for their misconduct. They can tell the board exactly what they did, why it was wrong, and what they have done in the years since. The Wilkie memo, issued in July 2018, explains why that evidence belongs in the case. It directs boards deciding questions of equity, injustice, or clemency to consider matters such as rehabilitation, acceptance of responsibility, changes in policy, and disparities in punishment. Its reach extends beyond discharge upgrades to other military record corrections within a board’s authority. Wilkie memorandum, attachment, paragraphs 4 and 6–7

One of Wilkie’s most consequential instructions is easy to overlook. Character and rehabilitation should carry more weight than achievement alone. A veteran need not build an impressive résumé to make a persuasive case. A letter from the supervisor who watched that veteran earn back trust, take responsibility for mistakes, and become the person new employees rely on can say more about rehabilitation than a list of job titles. The board retains discretion over the outcome. Wilkie explains why it should take that letter seriously. Wilkie memorandum, attachment, paragraphs 5 and 6(b)

The Kennedy settlement brought earlier Army decisions back for review

In Kennedy v. McCarthy, Army veterans challenged how the Army Discharge Review Board handled applications involving PTSD and related conditions. A federal court approved the class settlement on April 26, 2021. The agreement concerned Army procedures, including cases involving Army Reserve and Army National Guard veterans. Its automatic reconsideration provision applied to qualifying decisions of the Army Discharge Review Board. Court order approving the settlement, Kennedy settlement agreement, §§ II and IV

For qualifying decisions issued April 17, 2011, through April 26, 2021, the Army agreed to reconsider cases in which the applicant had received less than the full relief requested. Those veterans could add evidence, but the Army undertook to start the review itself. For qualifying decisions issued October 7, 2001, through April 16, 2011, the settlement provided notice of the opportunity to reapply. The agreement specifically identified the Army Board for Correction of Military Records as the route for those earlier applicants whose discharges fell outside the Discharge Review Board’s 15-year window. Kennedy settlement agreement, §§ IV.A–B, 10 U.S.C. § 1553(a)

That distinction mattered to thousands of people. By the time the parties signed the agreement, the Army had already identified about 3,500 decisions for reconsideration. Each veteran’s outcome still depended on the merits. What changed was who had to take the first step. For that group, a veteran who had accepted a denial and put the paperwork away could receive another review without having to discover the new guidance or file again. Kennedy settlement agreement, § IV.A.2–3

What would a fair record say today?

For the Soldier who missed those formations, a persuasive application might begin with three dates. When did he return from deployment? When did his performance first start to change? When did he first miss formation? A statement from someone who served with him can fill in what happened between those dates. A clinician can explain whether the symptoms fit that timeline. The veteran can acknowledge the absences, explain what was happening, and identify the precise change sought. Together, those pieces give the board a reason to reach a different judgment on facts the veteran has never disputed. Kurta memorandum, paragraphs 4–7 and 9–19

That is where these reforms have increased the opportunity for justice. A veteran can name what went unrecognized during service, show who they have become since separation, or ask a board to revisit a qualifying denial issued before it had the applicable guidance. What evidence would help the board understand why the entry on your military record is unjust, and what correction would make it fair?

Talk with Natalia

Start with a free, 30-minute consultation. Tell Natalia what’s happening, what you’re concerned about, and what you hope to accomplish.

Book a free consultationOr call 719-888-4970Military and veteran clients worldwide